German state-owned utility Uniper warned on Tuesday that it was likely to slow down a planned €8-B ($8.7-B) investment in cleaner fuels amid slower than expected demand for H2 from industry.
The comments reflect growing skepticism among German companies about whether long-standing government plans to rely more heavily on H2 to cut emissions are realistic and affordable.
Uniper, which was bailed out by Berlin during Europe's energy crisis in 2022, recently reviewed its strategy that targets €8 B in investments through 2030 with a focus on H2 and biomethane, finance chief Jutta Doenges said.
"We are now less optimistic about the timeline regarding the implementation of a green hydrogen economy," she told analysts after presenting an expected two-thirds drop in nine-month core profit. "We observe a mood of caution among potential B2B (business to business) customers to make a commitment for significant green hydrogen or ammonia supply offtake volumes."
So-called green H2 is produced using renewable power, and Germany's government has been betting on this fuel to help its economy become climate-neutral by 2045.
When asked about the impact of Uniper's slowdown in its H2 plan on the country's overall decarbonization ambitions, Germany's economy ministry acknowledged that ramping up a completely new H2 market is fraught with uncertainties.
The ministry said it was, however, important to create the necessary framework to promote the ramp-up, highlighting recent progress in establishing necessary infrastructure, regulatory framework and funding programs, including the country's core H2 network plans, officially approved last month.
"It is clear that we still have a lot of work ahead of us to further advance the ramp-up of the hydrogen economy," a spokesperson for the ministry said on Tuesday.
Doenges said the ramp-up of H2 power plants was expected to materialize more slowly than assumed 18 months ago, adding Uniper would "potentially move a little bit slower" on its strategy as a result. "We are adjusting the pace of our transformation," she said.
Uniper is preparing for a return to the stock market after Berlin acquired a 99.12% stake as part of its €13.5-B rescue, which was needed after Russian gas supplier Gazprom curbed and later stopped deliveries.
As part of efforts to smoothen the process, Uniper has begun repaying Germany, saying on Tuesday it had transferred €530 MM to the government in September.
The company said a separate chunk of provisions was now valued at just under €2.5 B and would likely be transferred in early 2025, while the final amount could still change.
($1 = €0.9181)